The 10 Best Wineries in Santa Ynez Valley

Santa Ynez Valley AVA is part of the beautiful Santa Barbara County wine region and the large Central Coast AVA. The AVA (American Viticultural Area) was officially established in 1983 and currently comprises 7,500 acres under vine. Sta. Rita Hills, Happy Canyon, Ballard Canyon, and the Los Olivos District AVAs are all nested within Santa Ynez Valley AVA.

Santa Ynez vineyard at sunset

The valley, which runs east to west, is formed between the Purisima Hills, the San Rafael Mountains, and the Santa Ynez Mountains. The Santa Ynez River runs through the valley out to the Pacific Ocean.

The proximity of the Pacific Ocean is key for the high quality wines produced in this region – the valley draws in and traps cool ocean air, helping maintain acidity in the grapes and lengthen the growing season. It gets gradually warmer further inland, allowing for a wide range of grapes to thrive in this area. Pinot Noir and Chardonnay rule in the cooler coastal region, while Rhone varieties, Cabernet, Merlot, and Sauvignon Blanc do well in the warmer inland vineyards.

Santa Ynez Valley’s other claim to fame (besides excellent wine) is that most of 2004’s Academy Award and Golden Globe winning movie Sideways was filmed here. The film is often credited with helping consumers discover the joy of Santa Barbara’s Pinot Noirs.

Santa Barbara County, as a whole, was named Wine Enthusiast Magazine’s Wine Region of the Year in 2021, and with good reason. Scenic coastal highways and rolling hills add visual appeal, while the fairly close proximity to Los Angeles makes traveling here easy. Popular towns in the area include Los Olivos, Santa Ynez and Solvang, all of which provide options for shopping, dining, and accommodations. Cheers!

To learn more about our winery ranking process, our CW score, or how we gather and analyze data, please click here.

Note: We do our best to maintain up to date information on all wineries featured. However, we recommend checking directly with a winery before planning a visit. If you find any information below that needs to be updated please let us know.

1.  Buscador Winery

top winery in Santa Ynez award

CW Score: 89.3

Website: buscadorwine.com

Address: 140 Industrial Way Unit D Buellton, CA 93427

Phone: 805-242-5206

Overview: Housed in an industrial warehouse, the Buscador Winery and tasting room offers visitors a unique experience. Guests are invited to get up close to the wine barrels, and the winemaker pours tastings from behind the bar.

Buscador focuses on producing wines from Bordeaux red varietals as well as red and white Rhone grapes along with the occasional surprise. The tasting room is open Friday through Monday from noon to 5 PM. 


2. Story of Soil

second best winery in Santa Ynez award

CW Score: 87.6

Website: storyofsoilwine.com

Address: 2928 San Marcos Ave Los Olivos, CA 93441

Phone: 805-686-1302

Overview: Story of Soil focuses on producing wines from single vineyards and single varieties, so that the final product truly tells a story of a sense of place. Current offerings include a number of single vineyard Pinot Noirs, along with a Syrah, Grenache, and Sauvignon Blanc.

Reservations for their seated tastings ($20) are recommended, but they do accommodate walk-ins when possible. Guests can also enjoy wine by the glass or bottle and can take advantage of their lovely patio space, too. 


3. Peake Ranch Winery

third best winery in Santa Ynez award

CW Score: 85.7

Website: peakeranch.com

Address: 7290 Santa Rosa Rd Buellton, CA 93427

Phone: 805-688-7093

Overview: Peake Ranch Winery produces wine exclusively from estate-grown grapes – they have three estate vineyards that they source from. Their signature varieties include Chardonnay, Pinot Noir (including a Pinot Noir rosé), and Rhone varieties such as Grenache and Syrah.

Guests can taste these while visiting the tasting room; tastings are $50 per person. While they do not serve food in the tasting room, you’re welcome to bring a picnic to enjoy during your visit.


4. Storm Wines

CW Score: 83.5

Website: stormwines.com

Overview: Storm Wines can be described as old meets new – they pride themselves on their mix of Old and New World winemaking approaches. Uniquely, Storm produces several different bottlings of Sauvignon Blanc made in varying styles. Pinot Noir is their signature red wine. Guests can try these and more when visiting.

The sprawling tasting room includes ample outdoor space, including several shady spots. Tasting reservations are recommended but not required. 


5. Margerum Wine Company Winery

CW Score: 81.7

Website: margerumwines.com

Address: 59 Industrial Way Buellton, CA 93427

Phone: 805-686-8500

Overview: Margerum Wine Company Winery produces a wide range of wines, including several whites, rosé, and reds, along with fortified wines and specialty amaro. Grapes for these wines are sourced from the estate vineyards as well as select partner vineyards throughout Santa Barbara County.

The Santa Barbara tasting room has something for everyone. Wine tastings are available, as well as wine by the glass or bottle. Margerum offers seasonal small bites, and be sure to check out the gift shop during your visit.


6. CrossHatch Winery

CW Score: 81.5

Website: crosshatchwinery.com

Address: 1090 Edison St #104 Santa Ynez, CA 93460

Phone: 805-691-9192

Overview: CrossHatch Winery has a new tasting room now open daily in Santa Ynez, where guests can enjoy a wine tasting, wine by the glass, or purchase bottles to go. The current tasting flight is $30 for five samples. Additionally, they offer several wine club options for guests who’d like to receive replenishment shipments of their fantastic wines.

CrossHatch specializes in blends, both red and white, with a heavy focus on Rhone grape varieties (such as Viognier, Grenache, and Syrah). Enjoy your wine on the sunny lawn out front of their tasting room!


7. Carhartt Family Wines

CW Score: 80.6

Website: carharttfamilywines.com

Address: 2939 Grand Ave Los Olivos, CA 93441

Phone: 805-693-5100

Overview: Carhartt Family Wines does not distribute their product, so a visit to the tasting room (also known as the ‘Carhartt Cabin’) is the only place to sample these wines.

This cozy space, open daily, offers a relaxed spot to taste through the Carhartt offerings. They also host weekly live music in the summertime. Carhartt Family produces a wine range of whites and reds, including a mix of single varietal wines and blends.


8. McClain Cellars

CW Score: 80.0

Website: mcclaincellars.com

Address: 140 Industrial Way Buellton, CA 93427

Phone: 805-426-4441

Overview: McClain Cellars has four different tasting rooms to check out during your visit to Santa Barbara County – two in Laguna Beach, one in Buellton, and one in Solvang.

While each location serves excellent wines (popular options include their sparkling wine and several signature white and red blends), they offer different amenities, from cellar tastings and barrel room viewings to custom artwork and corn hole tournaments. Hours vary by location, so make sure to check ahead when planning your visit.


9. The Brander Vineyard & Winery

CW Score: 78.3

Website: brander.com

Address: 2401 N Refugio Rd Santa Ynez, CA 93460

Phone: 805-688-2455

Overview: Brander Vineyard and Winery is especially renowned for their Sauvignon Blanc, but they offer a nice array of whites, reds, and rosé. The tasting room is open daily and reservations are recommended, but not required.

The Brander Museum of Folk Art is also on the property, offering guests the opportunity to take in some Latin American folk art while visiting. The winery is also home to a rental property that overlooks the vineyards (bookings can be made via the website).


10. Hitching Post Wines

CW Score: 78.2

Website: hpwines.com

Address: 420 CA-246 Buellton, CA 93427

Phone: 805-688-0676

Overview: Hitching Post Wines extends a few different tasting options to their guests. The Traditional Tasting is a flight of five wines for $20 per person; they also offer a reserve tasting and a private tasting with the winemaker.

Lunch, appetizers, and snacks are also available at various times throughout the day. There are walking paths weaving through the property; guests are welcome to buy a bottle and bring a picnic to enjoy onsite. Dogs are also welcome outside.


Plan Your Visit to the Top Wineries in Santa Ynez

With these remarkable wineries in mind, it’s time to start planning your visit. We’ve partnered with some of the top travel brands to help you secure the best deals available and to make your trip truly unforgettable.

ChoiceWineries.com is reader-supported. When you buy through the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Visit our disclaimer page for more information.

Unforgettable Experiences

Viator.com (a TripAdvisor company) is our recommended vendor for finding unbelievable local experiences to complement your time visiting wineries.

Guided tours, hot air balloon rides, and scavenger hunts are just a few of the types of excursions you can find to book on Viator.

Travel & Accommodations

Expedia.com is our recommended travel vendor for booking flights, hotels, rental cars, and more.

Great deals and discounted packages are just the start. Expedia will allow you to tailor your trip to fit your needs and preferences.

Whether you’re looking to book a first class flight, to stay at a 5 star hotel, or to book a quaint bed and breakfast, Expedia can help to secure your perfect travel arrangements across their vast network of travel and accommodation providers.


You might also enjoy…